The first round of open window grants were awarded in June 2009 and 18 cutting edge research proposals were selected. Over half of them are based in Africa, a third in Asia and the remaining in Latin America. These cover a variety of sectors, including: agriculture, education, governance, health, microcredit, social protection and water.

Lead researcher: Rachel Glennerster, Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL)
Sector: Social development, Gender and Inclusion
Country/Region: Bangladesh/South Asia
 
Lead researcher: Sudarno Sumarto, SMERU Research Institute
Sector: Social protection and risk management
Country/Region: Indonesia/East Asia and the Pacific
 
Lead researcher: Paul Gertler, University of California, Berkeley
Sector: Urban Development
Country/Region: Mexico/Latin America and the Caribbean
 
Lead researcher: Vivian Hoffmann, Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL)
Sector: Environment and natural resources management
Country/Region: Kenya/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Tristan Reed, Regents of the University of California
Sector: Public sector governance
Country/Region: Sierra Leone/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Pascaline Dupas, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) Affiliate
Sector: Financial and private sector development
Country/Region: Kenya/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Robert Ochai, The AIDS Support Organization (TASO), Uganda
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Uganda/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Esther Duflo, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) Affiliate
Country/Region: Ghana/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Tiwaporn Sutthiwongse, Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives, Royal Thai Government
Sector: Rural development
Country/Region: Thailand/ East Asia and the Pacific
 
Lead researcher: David Levine, Eugene E. and Catherine M. Trefeten, Regents of the University of California
Sector: Environment and natural resources management
Country/Region: Ghana/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Chloe OGara – Save the Children Federation, US
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Mozambique/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Martin J. Fisher, KickStart International
Sector: Rural development
Country/Region: Africa
 
Lead researcher: Dr. Nava Ashraf, Harvard Business School
Sector: Social development, gender and inclusion
Country/Region: Zambia/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Scott Rozelle, Stanford University
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: China/East Asia and the Pacific
 
Lead researcher: Paula Gadsden, Instituto Nacional de Salud Publica (INSP), Mexico
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Mexico/Latin America and the Caribbean
 
Lead researcher: Edward Miguel, Centre of Evaluation for Global Action (CEGA)
Sector: Education
Country/Region: Kenya/Africa
 
Lead researcher: Shama Mohammed, InterActive Research and Development (IRD)
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Pakistan/South Asia
 

Age at Marriage, Women’s Education, and Mother and Child Outcomes in Bangladesh

In Bangladesh, as in much of the developing world, early female marriage—defined as marriage before the age of 18—remains widespread despite age of consent laws banning the practice, government and NGO efforts to curtail it, increasing education levels, and economic growth. Early marriage is highly correlated with low levels of education, access to resources, mobility, and ultimately, poor health outcomes for young women and their children.
This study evaluates and builds on a program implemented by Save the Children (US) in collaboration with local nongovernmental organizations. It will engage approximately 47,000 adolescent girls between the ages of 10 and 19 in a variety of social, educational and nutritional interventions in order to identify effective and efficient strategies for empowering girls and delaying adolescent marriage.
The research seeks to improve the ability to understand and address the specific channels through which early marriage influences the health and well-being of adolescent girls and their offspring. To distinguish the impact of education on health and empowerment from the impact of delaying marriage on these same outcomes, Save the Children provided 4 litres of cooking oil every four months to adolescent girls between the ages of 15-17 on the condition that they remain unmarried.

Lead researcher: Rachel Glennerster, Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL)
Sector: Social development, Gender and Inclusion
Country/Region: Bangladesh/South Asia

An Impact Evaluation of the Unconditional Cash Transfer Program: Evidence from the Indonesian Large Scale Social Assistance

Indonesia implemented an Unconditional Cash Transfer (UCT) program to help poor households overcome the adverse effects of a massive reduction in fuel subsidies from October 2005 to September 2006. It was one of the largest UCT in the world tackling fuel subsidies. About 19 million households benefited from the intervention. The program was reintroduced from June to December 2008 following another reduction in fuel subsidies. 
The project will offer a rigorous quantitative evaluation of the impact of the Indonesian UCT program on household welfare, poverty dynamics and other socioeconomic outcomes. It will also directly assess the equity and efficiency implications of using a cash transfer to compensate households after cutbacks in government subsidies for important commodities such as fuel. The study will use nationally representative longitudinal panel data on households.
Given the scope and size of the Indonesian government’s investment in this program, this study will fill a gap in understanding the effectiveness and impact of the program.

Lead researcher: Sudarno Sumarto, SMERU Research Institute
Sector: Social protection and risk management
Country/Region: Indonesia/East Asia and the Pacific

Building a Brighter Future: A Randomized Experiment of Slum-Housing Upgrading in Mexico

Adequate housing, along with food and clothing, is considered by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as a basic requirement for achieving a minimum living standard. Yet, inadequate housing, a primary characteristic of slum dwellers, is a problem facing 45% of the global urban population.
Despite the importance of housing, there is surprisingly little scientific evidence on the causal effects of housing programs on the welfare of beneficiary populations in low-income countries.
The project will fill this gap by evaluating the impact of providing inexpensive basic pre-fabricated houses to extreme poor populations living in informal slums in Latin America. They work with a NGO, Un Techo Para Mi País (UTPMP), which is a youth-led program that provides such houses to extreme poor populations living in the slums of 14 Latin American countries.
The main objective of the program is to improve household well-being and increase the beneficiary household's probability of exiting extreme poverty. UTPMP targets households in sub-standard housing typically made of materials such as cardboard, tin and plastic, with dirt floors and lacking services such as water and sewage. 
The project proposes to evaluate the impact of UTPMP housing on physical and mental health, socio-economic, and security outcomes and also examine if there are spillovers to non-beneficiaries living in treatment communities.

Lead researcher: Paul Gertler, University of California, Berkeley
Sector: Urban Development
Country/Region: Mexico/Latin America and the Caribbean

Chlorine Dispensers: Scaling for Results

Two million children die of diarrheal disease each year and contaminated water is often to blame. Treating water with chlorine could substantially reduce this toll. The most common approach to chlorination in areas without piped water infrastructure is to offer small bottles of chlorine for sale to consumers. However, chlorine use has been slow to catch on in this system. 
In this Kenyan study area, for example, less than 10% of households regularly use chlorine at a monthly cost of approximately US$0.30, despite several years of vigorous social marketing that has raised awareness about the product.
Based on this finding, the team has developed a way to drastically cut the cost of chlorinating water by reducing packaging and distribution costs, which account for the majority of the price of chlorine sold in individually-packaged bottles by installing chlorine dispensers at communal water sources. Users turn a knob on the dispenser to release a pre-measured dose of chlorine appropriate to treat the volume of water typically collected. The presence of a dispenser provides a reminder to treat water and harness peer effects to help increase take-up.
Sustainability in this context requires that an affordable supply of chlorine is consistently available, and that dispensers are refilled on a regular basis (approximately monthly). Evidence on the health effects will help policy-makers determine if chlorine dispensers are a cost-effective investment.

Lead researcher: Vivian Hoffmann, Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL)
Sector: Environment and natural resources management
Country/Region: Kenya/Africa

Community Driven Development in Sierra Leone

GoBifo means “go forward” in Krio, the language spoken by 97% of Sierra Leone's population. GoBifo is a community driven development (CDD) pilot project in Sierra Leone that seeks to build social capital, trust and capacity for collective action in the communities where it works. 
The project’s designers sought to do this by establishing (or re-establishing) inclusive and representative Village Development Committees (VDCs) in communities and then training them in egalitarian development planning. VDCs were then given grants with which to carry out development projects they had chosen in the planning process.
The evaluation— led by the Evaluations Unit of Institutional Reform and Capacity Building Project (a project of the Government of Sierra Leone and the World Bank) with technical assistance from the Centre for Evaluation of Global Action — is designed to test the ability of a participatory CDD approach to build social capital and increase the inclusiveness of community decision making in a post conflict environment where a lack of participatory decision making in local politics was seen by many as a contributor to the long running conflict in the country. 
The objective is to inform the project development and seek funding to scale up community level CDD programs and integrate them into one of the large scale community development programs in Sierra Leone.
The evaluation will also seek to develop and refine new participatory tools to identify much sought after, yet hard to measure development outcomes such as trust and participatory decision making.

Lead researcher: Tristan Reed, Regents of the University of California
Sector: Public sector governance
Country/Region: Sierra Leone/Africa

Enabling Microenterprise Development in sub-Saharan Africa through the Provision of Financial Services

How do rural micro-enterprises function, and how can one identify savings and credit interventions to enable entrepreneurship and improve the living standards in sub-Saharan Africa?
The project aims to shed some light on these issues by conducting a randomized controlled trial involving 600 micro-entrepreneurs in Western Kenya who are provided with access to financial services.
The proposed study will generate rigorous evidence on the effectiveness of financial services for the very poor, a population which has been largely understudied to date, despite their importance. 
The study will provide evidence on which factors constrain entrepreneurship and, by extension, growth and development in poor countries. It will also generate a unique panel dataset that will be of use to any researcher or practitioner interested in African entrepreneurs.

Lead researcher: Pascaline Dupas, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) Affiliate
Sector: Financial and private sector development
Country/Region: Kenya/Africa

Estimating the Effectiveness of a Food Supplementation Intervention Integrated into an AIDS Care and Treatment Program

Food and nutrition security are increasingly being recognized as fundamental to the prevention, care and treatment of HIV and AIDS. International organizations such as WHO, UNAIDS, WFP and FAO have recommended integration of food assistance into AIDS care and treatment programs.
This study - a collaboration between The AIDS Support Organization (TASO), The Regional Network on AIDS, Livelihoods and Food Security (RENEWAL) coordinated by IFPRI, and WFP - aims to evaluate the impact of household food ration on clinical, socioeconomic and behavioural outcomes elabourated in the above section.
Given the ethical considerations in randomizing food assistance to People Living With HIV/AIDS (PLWHIV) in the context of chronic malnutrition and food insecurity, this impact evaluation employs a quasi experimental design, nested within the current TASO program activities. WFP collaborates with TASO to provide food assistance to HIV positive clients in some of the TASO centres.
The project will employ propensity matching methods with difference- in -difference estimations to examine changes that occur as a result of food assistance to evaluate the impact of food supplementation on: a) HIV progression, medical, nutritional and quality of life, high risk behaviour, labour productivity and food security outcomes of PLWHIV, and b) socioeconomic, health, and nutritional outcomes at the household level including food security, household dietary diversity, household expenditures, intra-household labour reallocation, assets and savings, indebtedness, perceived well-being, mental health and child growth.

Lead researcher: Robert Ochai, The AIDS Support Organization (TASO), Uganda
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Uganda/Africa

Estimating the Impact and Cost-Effectiveness of Expanding Secondary Education in Ghana

As progress is made towards universal primary school enrolment, and millions of children around the world complete primary schooling and hope to move on to a secondary school, an important question for policymakers is emerging. How quickly can access to secondary education be expanded?
In collaboration with the Government of Ghana, the project examines the medium and long-term impacts of secondary school for a cohort of students in Ghana who earned admission into a senior secondary school but could not afford to pay the fees. It identified 1,800 students who took the Bachelor of Early Childhood Education (BECE) in April 2008 and gained admission into a senior secondary school for September 2008, but who did not enrol because of financial distress. Out of these 1,800 students, 600 have been selected through random assignment to each receive a 4-year scholarship to attend the senior secondary school they were admitted to, starting January 2009.
The study tracks the 1,800 students from 2009 until 2018. Follow-up surveys with them, and the households that they reside in, are conducted every three years. The follow-up surveys will include questions on health, labour market outcomes, and fertility and marriage. This will enable to measure the medium and long-term effects of acquiring secondary education on multiple aspects of life and well-being.

Lead researcher: Esther Duflo, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) Affiliate
Country/Region: Ghana/Africa

Impact of the irrigation improvement component of Agricultural Sector Program Loan

There are few examples of rigorous impact evaluations of irrigation improvement projects, and such evaluations entail significant problems of identification and attribution due to the geographical uniqueness of each project and the lack of appropriate base-line information. 
This impact evaluation will conduct quantitative and qualitative research on two medium scale government irrigation projects in North-west Thailand to identify and quantify the impacts on productivity and improvements of irrigation infrastructure, water management institutions, and agricultural extension. 
The project involves an innovative use of Geographical Information System (GIS) tracking, to visually identify plots for farm survey, and to assess changes induced by the irrigation improvement project.
Propensity score matching on observables and instrumental variables approaches will be used to identify the impacts of the project, and plot transition probabilities to quantify impacts for cost-benefit analysis.

Lead researcher: Tiwaporn Sutthiwongse, Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives, Royal Thai Government
Sector: Rural development
Country/Region: Thailand/ East Asia and the Pacific

Improved Cook stoves in the Tumu region of Ghana

Under current trends, household energy use in Africa alone will produce 6.7 billion tons of carbon by 2050. Tragically, the stoves that create this carbon will also create indoor air pollution that will kill millions of children. At the same time, deforestation will harm local ecosystems and biodiversity.
Improved stoves have the potential to reduce all of these problems. Importantly, several mechanisms already exist and new ones are evolving for rich nations to subsidize improved stoves that reduce greenhouse gases.
The research in this proposal will examine the scale-up of access to carbon credits and pioneer a market for health credits to finance further deployment of improved cook stoves across sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia. The implementing partner Plan Ghana is eager to expand the pilot improved stove project to hundreds or even thousands of villages in Ghana if sustainable impact-based financing can be found.
Plan Ghana is also part of a much larger NGO, Plan International, which operates in 60 countries worldwide. The opportunity is vast, as there are hundreds of millions of inefficient biomass stoves in use. Establishing a market for health credits will challenge accepted paradigms for financing global health and can ultimately transform the broader development agenda.

Lead researcher: David Levine, Eugene E. and Catherine M. Trefeten, Regents of the University of California
Sector: Environment and natural resources management
Country/Region: Ghana/Africa

Learning and Growing in the Shadow of HIV/AIDS: A Prospective Randomized Evaluation of the Effects of Escolinhas on Young Children in Mozambique

Early years of life are pivotal in forming the foundations for healthy development and providing children and their societies the opportunity to reach their full potential. Programs to promote early childhood development (ECD) are most critical in Africa, where children face the myriad risks of disease, malnutrition, conflict and low-quality education systems. Governments in Africa urgently need evidence about the effectiveness of ECD programs to help them make informed decisions about the allocation of resources in their struggle to meet basic needs and secure a better future for their citizens.
In response to this imperative for actionable evidence, Save the Children and the World Bank are collaborating with local partners to carry out a ground-breaking evaluation of an early childhood development (ECD) program in Gaza Province, Mozambique. This ECD program enrols vulnerable children ages 3-5 – those living amidst high levels of poverty and/or affected by HIV/AIDS – and provides them with a high-quality but low-cost and fiscally scale-able model of pre-school education that helps build the foundation for lifelong learning. 

Lead researcher: Chloe OGara – Save the Children Federation, US
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Mozambique/Africa

Monitoring and Assessing the Impacts of KickStart’s Low Cost Farm Equipment on Poverty Reduction in Africa

The NGO KickStart International initiated a market-driven initiative to manufacture and sell low cost treadle pumps and other productive assets designed and adapted for poor farmers in Africa. 
The main objective of the proposed impact evaluation project is to increase the capacity of KickStart to monitor and assess the impacts of its product on household income, education and the environment. A secondary objective is to identify the constraints that limit acquisition of pumps and other productive assets sold by KickStart.
This project will produce evidence to design and implement more effective and sustainable small-scale irrigation and asset development programs, and to develop state-of-art impact assessment system for market-led and private sector poverty reduction programs.

Lead researcher: Martin J. Fisher, KickStart International
Sector: Rural development
Country/Region: Africa

No margin, No mission? Evaluating the Role of Incentives in the Distribution of Public Goods

Non-profit and public organizations increasingly rely on the services of community members to deliver and promote health goods, yet research on the motivation and performance of these agents is scarce.
This project performs a rigorous evaluation of different incentive schemes to motivate community-based agents engaged in the distribution of female condoms in Zambia. Female condoms present a valuable technology for the prevention of HIV/AIDS and other Sexually Transmitted Infections and give women the ability to take protection into their own hands.  
While female condom uptake has been high in some parts of Southern Africa, barriers to adoption similar to those accompanying many new technologies continue to hinder usage in many communities.  Society for Family Health in Lusaka, Zambia is relying on a novel distribution channel – hairdressers and barbers – to promote the female condom and to provide information to customers about its proper use and the dangers of unprotected sex. 

Lead researcher: Dr. Nava Ashraf, Harvard Business School
Sector: Social development, gender and inclusion
Country/Region: Zambia/Africa

Paying For Performance in China’s Battle Against Anaemia

Anaemia - or iron deficiencies - affects nearly a quarter of students from poor rural areas of China. In other words, there are up to 20 to 30 million children with anaemia in the country. Anaemia has been shown to reduce cognitive ability, lead to learning problems and be associated with poor school attendance, bad behaviour and overall poor educational performance. In the past, there have been top-down efforts to reduce anaemia, but, they have had mixed results.
Large scale field experiments, run collaboratively with local and regional educational agencies, will be set up to examine the incentives of school principals in China’s rural primary schools in combating anaemia. The Randomized Control Trials (RCT) approach will facilitate the evaluation and provide policy makers clear and simple evidence of different ways to address this problem. One of the key treatments will examine how incentives can be designed to induce local educators to solve anaemia and improve educational outcomes.
The evaluation will provide evidence on the effectiveness, including cost-effectiveness, of using Pay for Performance incentive mechanisms (in lieu of direct monitoring) to deliver health inputs, to realize health outcomes and to achieve educational impacts.

Lead researcher: Scott Rozelle, Stanford University
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: China/East Asia and the Pacific

The Impact of Day Care on Maternal Labour Supply and Child Development in Mexico

Female labour force participation and early childhood development are two key policy areas facing developing country governments. A number of countries have turned to either opening or subsidizing day care to promote labour force participation through relieving one of the most pressing constraints faced by working parents, i.e. access to reliable and affordable childcare. 
Many hypothesize that the higher unemployment rates and fewer working hours for females, compared to their male counterparts, are –at least partly- due to conflicting demands on women’s time: taking care of children and working for income. By increasing access to quality day care, governments hope to be able to improve the nutritional and cognitive development of young children.
Day care programs can only be effective if they not only improve maternal labour market outcomes, but also do not negatively affect child health and development. The project will study the effects of the new Mexican day care program, Guarderias y Estancias Infantiles para Apoyar a Madres Trabajadoras (GEI) on maternal (labour market) outcomes, on child health, nutrition and development and other time use (including education) of other family members.

Lead researcher: Paula Gadsden, Instituto Nacional de Salud Publica (INSP), Mexico
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Mexico/Latin America and the Caribbean

Vocational Education in Kenya: A Randomized Evaluation

This project, the first randomized impact evaluation of its kind on vocational education intervention in Western Kenya, builds on ten years of uniquely detailed educational, health and cognitive information for over 5,000 Kenyan adolescents contained in the Kenyan Life Panel Survey (KLPS). 
By drawing its sample from this detailed panel, the project will be able to determine which individual level characteristics impact ones returns from vocational schooling. 
Further, the study seeks to shed light on important policy issues related to information gaps, the demand for vocational schooling, access to private vocational schooling, and institution level determinants of quality through a factorial design featuring an information intervention and innovative voucher delivery.
Implementation began in 2008 with the recruitment of approximately 2,150 out-of-school youths (ranging in age from 18-26) drawn from the KLPS sample. Applicants were required to attend two program information meetings, participate in a short survey on expected returns, rank their preferred schools/courses, and submit a letter of support from a school or local authority. 
The analysis of pre-information intervention beliefs about returns to vocational schooling, preference rankings, and actual treatment and control 2009 enrolment follow-up data, will generate important evidence on educational demand in a low-information environment.
The proposed medium-term follow-up survey (2010-2012), will target all 2,150 individuals in the sample and assess vocational trainings impacts on employment, migration, fertility and other life outcomes. In particular, it will explore whether subsidized vocational schooling can enable the unemployed and those with little formal schooling to move into new and higher paying occupations, providing crucial information for policymakers in Africa and elsewhere.

Lead researcher: Edward Miguel, Centre of Evaluation for Global Action (CEGA)
Sector: Education
Country/Region: Kenya/Africa

X out TB : Monitoring Patient Compliance with Tuberculosis Treatment Regimens

Treatment for tuberculosis is long, complicated, and can cause uncomfortable side-effects. As a result, roughly 40% of patients worldwide do not complete the full course of treatment. Such non-compliance is in part responsible for the nearly two million annual TB deaths and the rapidly emerging problem of drug-resistant bacteria. 
In Karachi, Pakistan, the incidence of TB is believed to be particularly high, with 13,332 patients registered under the National TB Control Programme (NTP) in 2007.  Increasingly, the problem of non-compliance is leading to the emergence of multi-drug resistant TB (MDRTB), a form of TB that is more expensive and difficult to treat. 
Of 7,185 new pulmonary cases studied in Karachi in 2006, 12% were reported to have defaulted on treatment. The system currently recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) for tackling the problem of non-compliance is Directly Observed Therapy Short-Course (DOTS), which involves on-site, in-person monitoring of compliance with medication. DOTS programmes in Karachi use health workers, health clinic staff, or treatment supporters, who are usually family members, as monitors. However, there is no way of verifying whether and to what extent patients are complying with their drug regimen. 
In this study, Interactive Research and Development (IRD) plans to evaluate “X out TB,” a new monitoring system developed by Innovations in International Health.  Patients will be asked to urinate daily on test strips that detect whether or not they have taken their medication. These strips will be dispensed automatically each day by a dispenser provided to the patient to take home. If the test is positive (the patient did take his/her drugs), the strip will reveal a unique code that the patient can type into their cell phone and send as a text message to a central database. Positive compliance will be rewarded with a transfer of a small monetary credit on their cell-phone at the end of the week.
InterActive Research and Development (IRD) seeks to determine the program impacts of “X out TB” through administering a randomized control trial among newly diagnosed TB patients in Karachi, Pakistan.  

Lead researcher: Shama Mohammed, InterActive Research and Development (IRD)
Sector: Health/HIV
Country/Region: Pakistan/South Asia

 

3ie Impact | Expert Roster | Advocacy Campaigns | Grants Overview | Proposal Preparation Grants | Open Window | Social Protection Thematic Window | Systematic Reviews
Enduring Questions | Journal Development Effectiveness
Copyright © 2012 International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie). All rights reserved.