Agricultural Insurance Evidence Programme

Neil Palmer (CIAT)

Agriculture is a major source of sustenance for rural populations in low- and lower middle income countries. Farmers face numerous risks, including crop and livestock losses due to weather, pests, diseases and price fluctuations. In recent years, agricultural insurance has gained increased attention as a tool to provide smallholder farmers and their households with much-needed safety nets by enabling them to transfer risk to a third party. There is, however, a dearth of evidence on whether these insurance products are successful in improving smallholder farmers’ welfare. To close this gap, 3ie is supporting the generation of policy-relevant evidence on factors that affect successful uptake of agricultural insurance among smallholder farmers.

To help inform programme design, 3ie commissioned a scoping report to take stock of existing evidence and identify key research areas based on gaps in evidence found through a mapping exercise. In phase one, 3ie awarded 14 grants for formative or process evaluations of programmes focused on increasing the uptake of agricultural insurance. In phase two, 3ie gave six teams additional funding to conduct full impact evaluations. These studies will contribute to the evidence base on the effectiveness of financial instruments in reducing, mitigating and transferring risks faced by smallholder farmers. 

The UK Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office is funding this programme.

For more information, please write to info@3ieimpact.org. To receive alerts about call for proposals, please sign up here.

Related content

Assessment of community-based crop micro insurance for climate-related risks offered to smallholder farmers and marginalised communities in India

Other evaluation 3ie 2020
 
Authors of this process evaluation report assess the factors that affect the demand for agriculture insurance offered to smallholder farmers by community-based mutual-aid schemes and how effective is the crop insurance component of CBMAS in providing financial protection to insured farmers.

Formative evaluation on increasing the uptake of ACRE Hakika in Kenya

Other evaluation 3ie 2020
 
Authors of this formative evaluation report look at factors behind an increase in uptake of a mobile-based agricultural insurance product, ACRE Hakika — that uses a rainfall-based index. This product can secure the livelihood and incomes of local farmers in Kenya by providing coverage from the effects of unpredictable weather.

Understanding the potential of crop insurance in India: a study of the Prime Minister’s Crop Insurance Scheme

Other evaluation 3ie 2020
 
Authors of this process evaluation report explores the feasibility and acceptability of using crop insurance by various stakeholders, analysing their experiences and roles during the implementation process of the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana, in the state of Karnataka, India.

Uptake and evaluation of innovative insurance embedded credit for promoting resilience and livelihoods for smallholder in Kenya

Other evaluation 3ie 2020
 
Authors of this report evaluate the impacts of implementing an innovative risk management solution, Risk-Contingent Credit for smallholder wheat and maize farmers in Kenya.

Evaluating the efficacy of an app-based livestock insurance scheme in Gujarat, India

Other evaluation 3ie 2020
 
Authors of this formative evaluation report assess whether a mobile-app platform that digitises the in-field enrolment process and claims process for livestock insurance, combined with awareness programmes like cooperative society engagements and door-to-door marketing, can improve livestock insurance penetration and uptake.

Bundling weather index insurance and credit in Senegal: contributors and constraints to take-up

Other evaluation 3ie 2020
 
Authors of this formative evaluation report look at various bundled products that can increase weather index based insurance take-up in Senegal.

Uptake and evaluation of innovative insurance-embedded credit for promoting resilience and livelihoods for smallholder maize farmers in Kenya

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Apurba Shee, Liangzhi You, Yanyan Liu, Simon Kimenju
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Creating informed demand and impacts through innovative and cost effective extension in Kenya

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Andrew Mude, Nathan Jensen, Duncan D. Khalai, Rupsha Banerjee, Diba D Galgallo,
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Picture-based crop insurance: evaluating the impact of using smartphone camera data for claims verification in India

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Berber Kramer, Francisco Ceballos, Samyuktha Kannan, Uttam Kumar, Azad Mishra,
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Enhancing access to index-based weather agricultural insurance in Burkina Faso: a new marketing approach

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Harounan Kazianga, Zaki Wahhaj, Alassane Koulibaly, Souleymane Zare, ,
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Bundling weather index-based insurance with loans in Senegal: evaluating impact on insurance take-up and farmers' well being

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Mame Mor Anta Syll, Assane Faye, Hamidou Diop, Moustapha Fall, Seydina Ousmane Sene
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Insuring farmers against weather shocks: Evidence from India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2017
 

This impact evaluation by Tobacman et al. examines the long-term impacts of rainfall insurance in Gujarat, India.

Smallholder access to weather securities in India: demand and impact on production decisions

Impact evaluation 3ie 2015
 

Weather index insurance (WII) has had low demand and uptake among farmers despite a recent surge in interest among private companies and policymakers.

Enhancing food production and food security through improved inputs

Impact evaluation 3ie 2015
 

In Tanzania, agriculture accounts for 27 per cent of GDP, 80 per cent of employment and 75 per cent of household income. It is a key component of the country strategy for poverty reduction.

Providing collateral and improving product market access for smallholder farmers: a randomised evaluation of inventory credit in Sierra Leone

Impact evaluation 3ie 2015
 

Inventory credit can be an important instrument in helping farmers benefit from large inter-seasonal volatility of agricultural prices.

A randomised evaluation of the effects of an agricultural insurance programme on rural households’ behaviour: evidence from China

Impact evaluation 3ie 2014
 

The provision of weather insurance is a potential way of shielding farmers from weather related shocks and reducing poverty.

Uptake and evaluation of innovative insurance-embedded credit for promoting resilience and livelihoods for smallholder maize farmers in Kenya

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Apurba Shee, Liangzhi You, Yanyan Liu, Simon Kimenju
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Creating informed demand and impacts through innovative and cost effective extension in Kenya

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Andrew Mude, Nathan Jensen, Duncan D. Khalai, Rupsha Banerjee, Diba D Galgallo,
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Picture-based crop insurance: evaluating the impact of using smartphone camera data for claims verification in India

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Berber Kramer, Francisco Ceballos, Samyuktha Kannan, Uttam Kumar, Azad Mishra,
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Enhancing access to index-based weather agricultural insurance in Burkina Faso: a new marketing approach

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Harounan Kazianga, Zaki Wahhaj, Alassane Koulibaly, Souleymane Zare, ,
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Bundling weather index-based insurance with loans in Senegal: evaluating impact on insurance take-up and farmers' well being

Impact evaluation 3ie Publication type : 3ie-funded ongoing study
Author : Mame Mor Anta Syll, Assane Faye, Hamidou Diop, Moustapha Fall, Seydina Ousmane Sene
Sector : Agriculture fishing and forestry

Does agricultural certification improve well-being?

Systematic review Brief 3ie 2017
 
This brief is based on a systematic review that assesses the impact of agriculture certification schemes for improving socially sustainable and fairer production for smallholder farmers and workers.

Agricultural risk and mitigation gap map

Evidence gap map

This map, funded by the UK Department for International Development, presents existing evidence on agricultural insurance interventions that aim to improve smallholder farmer resilience in L&MICs.

View brief | View report

There are no replication studies