Promoting Latrine Use in Rural India Evidence Programme

ADB

Safe sanitation is a key determinant of many public health outcomes and ending open defecation is necessary in order to achieve safe sanitation. To this end, the Indian government has led a massive sanitation programme, Swachh Bharat Abhiyan - Gramin, to improve latrine access and use. However, there is growing awareness that access and use are not the same. 3ie supported five studies to promote latrine use in rural India. Four of these studies implemented and evaluated behaviour change interventions targeting barriers to use. The fifth considered the challenges related to measuring latrine use by comparing responses to household and individual-level latrine use questions.

A behavioural science approach

During the same period as the Swachh Bharat mission, 3ie supported four behaviour science-informed interventions to promote latrine use in Bihar, Odisha, Gujarat and Karnataka. In each state, formative studies revealed unique barriers to latrine use; including, habit and socialization, negative attitudes to latrines and fear of pits filling, among others. Interventions were specifically designed to address local barriers using behaviour science approaches to promote latrine use.

These studies all employed different approaches to target locally relevant barriers to latrine use with varying success. Data on latrine use was collected before the interventions and one year later to estimate the impacts of these interventions. In Odisha and Karnataka, there were meaningful and significant increases in latrine use in intervention sites when compared to control sites. There was a small, but statistically significant, increase in use in Gujarat, and no effect in Bihar.

 

 


Measuring latrine use

The measurement of latrine use has been challenging as it is prone to inaccuracy due to social desirability and recall bias. 3ie commissioned an additional study to investigate challenges related to the measurement of latrine use. This study tested whether responses to household-level questions differed from responses to individual-level questions. Researchers also compared latrine use measurements across different settings in rural India using standardized methods and practices.

Participants were asked either a balanced, individual-level question regarding latrine use or an imbalanced, household-level question. The individual-level question was preceded by an acknowledgement of the various habits that people have regarding latrine use in order to reduce pressure to report it in a socially desirable way. The household-level question asked about the usual behaviour of the family and included a variety of options, the last of which was open defecation. Results show that reported latrine use was lower when the individual-level question was used rather than the household-level question. This shows that the framing of the question regarding latrine use had a meaningful impact on reported rates, therefore, it is important to make improvements in how latrine use is measured.  

View full report


3ie is collaborating with the Research Institute for Compassionate Economics (r.i.c.e.) on this grant programme. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation has provided funding support for this programme.

To know more about how we are contributing to the WASH sector, download our brochure here.

For more information, please write to info@3ieimpact.org. To receive alerts about calls for proposals, please sign up here.


SUSANA 3ie is proud to be a partner of the Sustainable Sanitation Alliance (SuSanA). SuSanA is an open international alliance whose members share a   common vision on sustainable sanitation and are dedicated to understanding viable and sustainable sanitation solutions.


 

Related content

Effectiveness of a rural sanitation programme on diarrhoea, soil-transmitted helminth infection and malnutrition in India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2016
This report is based on a cluster-randomised evaluation conducted in 100 villages of Odisha to test the effectiveness of a rural sanitation intervention that was part of the India’s Total Sanitation Campaign.

Promoting latrine use in India

Scoping paper 3ie 2017

To inform 3ie’s Promoting Latrine Use in Rural India Thematic Window, we undertook a scoping study to identify the state of rigorous evidence in this area and to find out what decision makers, impl

Does building more toilets stop the spread of disease? Impact evidence from India

Impact evaluation Brief 3ie 2015
Over one-third of the 2.5 billion people worldwide who do not have access to improved sanitation live in India. Nearly 69 per cent of the population practise open defecation. Typically, the government of India’s national sanitation schemes have focused on building more latrines for reducing open defecation, health-related illness and child malnutrition.

Running water, working toilets and safe hygiene practices

Impact evaluation Brief 3ie 2009
The world is falling behind its targets to improve people’s access to sanitation, with major health costs. There is strong evidence that both sanitation and hygiene interventions are highly effective in reducing risks of diarrhoea, however public health promotion appears more cost-effective.

Measurement of latrine use in rural India

Other evaluation 3ie 2019
To understand the effectiveness of efforts to support latrine us, the behaviour must be accurately measured. This study compares reported rates of latrine use between an individual-level, balanced question and a household-level imbalanced question.

The 5 Star Toilet Campaign: improving toilet use in rural Gujarat

Impact evaluation 3ie 2020
This impact evaluation evaluated the effect of the 5 Star Toilet Campaign on toilet use in rural Gujarat. The Campaign was launched to address the complex determinants of low toilet use and improve use among all members of households having access to government or contractor-built toilets in selected villages of Bhavnagar, Gujarat.

Improving households’ attitudes and behaviours to increase toilet use in Bihar, India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Shruti Viswanathan, Ruhi Saith, Arpita Chakraborty, Nikita Purty, Niyati Malhotra, Pratima Singh, Priyanjali Mitra, Vinaya Padmanabhan, Saugato Datta, John Harris, Suman Gidwani, Roufi Williams, Elizabeth Florence, Sherin Daniels
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management

Impacts of low-cost interventions to improve latrine use and safe disposal of child faeces in rural Odisha, India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Bethany A. Caruso, Gloria D. Sclar, Parimita Routray, Corey Nagel, Fiona Majori, Steven Sola, Will Koehne, Renee Deshay, Shivika Udaipuria, Rebekah Williams, Thomas Clasen
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management

Promoting Latrine Use In Rural Karnataka Using The Risks, Attitudes, Norms Abilities And Self-Regulation (RANAS) Approach

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Max Friedrich, Tejaswi Balasundaram, Arundati Muralidharan, VR Raman, Hans-Joachim Mosler
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management

The 5 Star Toilet Campaign: Improving Toilet Use In Rural Gujarat

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Kavita Chauhan, Wolf Peter Schmidt, Robert Aunger, Balaji Gopalan, Deepak Saxena, S. Yashobant, Vebhav Patwardhan, Val Curtis
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management

Promoting latrine use in rural Karnataka using the risks, attitudes, norms, abilities and self-regulation (RANAS) approach

Impact evaluation 3ie 2020
While the Swachh Bharat Mission in India has been successful in boosting latrine coverage, actual latrine use remains low in many areas of the country.

Impacts of low-cost interventions to improve latrine use and safe disposal of child faeces in rural Odisha, India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2020
Authors of this impact evaluation report examines the impact of a multi-level intervention on latrine use and safe child faeces disposal behaviour in rural Odisha.

Improving households’ attitudes and behaviours to increase toilet use in Bihar, India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2020
Authors of this impact evaluation report evaluate the impact of a behaviourally-informed intervention in increasing intent, and habit, of toilet use among toilet-owning households in rural Bihar.

Community toilet use in Indian slums: willingness-to-pay and the role of informational and supply side constraints

Impact evaluation 3ie 2020
Authors of this impact evaluation report examine if community toilet related supply-side improvements and information campaigns can have an impact on the users’ willingness to pay and the overall quality and usage of these community toilets in the cities of Lucknow and Kanpur in India.

The 5 Star Toilet Campaign: improving toilet use in rural Gujarat

Impact evaluation 3ie 2020
This impact evaluation evaluated the effect of the 5 Star Toilet Campaign on toilet use in rural Gujarat. The Campaign was launched to address the complex determinants of low toilet use and improve use among all members of households having access to government or contractor-built toilets in selected villages of Bhavnagar, Gujarat.

Effectiveness of a rural sanitation programme on diarrhoea, soil-transmitted helminth infection and malnutrition in India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2016
This report is based on a cluster-randomised evaluation conducted in 100 villages of Odisha to test the effectiveness of a rural sanitation intervention that was part of the India’s Total Sanitation Campaign.

Improving households’ attitudes and behaviours to increase toilet use in Bihar, India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Shruti Viswanathan, Ruhi Saith, Arpita Chakraborty, Nikita Purty, Niyati Malhotra, Pratima Singh, Priyanjali Mitra, Vinaya Padmanabhan, Saugato Datta, John Harris, Suman Gidwani, Roufi Williams, Elizabeth Florence, Sherin Daniels
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management

Impacts of low-cost interventions to improve latrine use and safe disposal of child faeces in rural Odisha, India

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Bethany A. Caruso, Gloria D. Sclar, Parimita Routray, Corey Nagel, Fiona Majori, Steven Sola, Will Koehne, Renee Deshay, Shivika Udaipuria, Rebekah Williams, Thomas Clasen
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management

Promoting Latrine Use In Rural Karnataka Using The Risks, Attitudes, Norms Abilities And Self-Regulation (RANAS) Approach

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Max Friedrich, Tejaswi Balasundaram, Arundati Muralidharan, VR Raman, Hans-Joachim Mosler
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management

The 5 Star Toilet Campaign: Improving Toilet Use In Rural Gujarat

Impact evaluation 3ie 2019 Publication type : 3ie series report
Author : Kavita Chauhan, Wolf Peter Schmidt, Robert Aunger, Balaji Gopalan, Deepak Saxena, S. Yashobant, Vebhav Patwardhan, Val Curtis
Sector : Water sanitation and waste management
There are no systematic reviews
There are no evidence gap maps
There are no replication studies