Cash and change: a replication study of a cash transfer experiment in Malawi

Cash and change: a replication study of a cash transfer experiment in Malawi

3ie Replication paper 21, 2019

Maira Emy Reimão

Unconditional cash transfers are increasingly held as a benchmark in development research and practice, against which, it is argued, other interventions should be compared for impact and cost-effectiveness. Baird and colleagues (2011) is one of few studies to test this assertion in practice. They empirically compare, using randomisation, the impact of unconditional to conditional transfers. This is a tremendous contribution to the literature on both approaches and disentangling the roles of the transfer versus conditionality.

Maira Reimão conducted a replication of the original study. The exercise was constrained by the fact that not all data used in the original study were accessible – while the dataset for the push-button replication is complete, only household survey data are publicly available in raw form. Nevertheless, the results are generally the same as in the original paper for the parts that are replicable, including the key finding that unconditional cash transfers decrease the likelihood of early marriage and pregnancy while the conditional cash transfers do not.

Apart from push-button and pure replication, Reimão also carried out a measurement and estimation analysis, and considered the effects on primary and secondary school girls separately – or, alternatively, on girls with stronger school attachment (i.e. closer to the expected grade for age) separately from girls with a history of repetition and/or dropouts (i.e. lower grade than expected for age).

She finds that the unconditional cash transfers decrease the likelihood of pregnancy and marriage among primary school girls and girls with a stronger attachment to school. However, the finding is specific. Those transfers decrease the likelihood only of marriage for secondary school girls and those with a weaker school attachment. The impact on marriage for secondary school girls is larger than for primary school girls. This is complicated by the fact that the effect is concentrated on girls who are the only beneficiaries in the household.

In terms of policy, these results indicate that unconditional cash transfers may be a powerful tool for decreasing pregnancy and marriage rates among teenage girls, but particularly for decreasing the likelihood of pregnancy among girls in primary school and with a strong attachment to school. The exploratory analysis also points to a warning regarding conditional cash transfers, as it might increase the likelihood of pregnancy among older girls.

Biometric Smartcards and payment disbursement: a replication study of a state capacity-building experiment in India

Biometric Smartcards and payment disbursement: a replication study of a state capacity-building experiment in India

Replication paper 3ie 2019
The National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme and Social Security Pension are two of the largest employment programmes in Andhra Pradesh. Muralidharan and colleagues (2016) investigated the impacts of biometrically-authenticated payment infrastructure (Smartcards) on beneficiaries of the two employment programmes.

RPS22

Risk sharing and transaction costs: a replication study of evidence from Kenya’s mobile money revolution

Replication paper 3ie 2019
This replication study starts with the twin strategies of push-button and pure replications of the original study. It then followed this up with various consistency and robustness checks, such as propensity score matching and the Tobit model specification.

Impact of unconditional cash transfers: a replication study of the short-term effects in Kenya

Impact of unconditional cash transfers: a replication study of the short-term effects in Kenya

Replication paper 3ie 2019

Wang and colleagues replicate the results of a randomized evaluation carried out by Haushofer and Shapiro in 2016.

3ie Replication paper 18

Savings revisited: a replication study of a savings intervention in Malawi

Replication paper 3ie 2018

Jesper Stage and Tharshini Thangavelu replicate the results of a randomized evaluation carried out by Lasse Brune and colleagues in 2016 in Malawi.

RPS19

Mobile money and its impact on improving living conditions in Niger: a replication study

Replication paper 3ie

Edmundo Beteta and colleagues replicate the results of a randomized evaluation carried out by Aker and colleagues in 2016 in Niger.